Thursday, March 17, 2011

"It's important for mothers to recognize that their daughters are psychologically different from them."

Dr. Kindlon wrote the above quote, and it has bothered me long after I read past the page. The premise of this book is based on the new phenomenon of the alpha girl. I don't really believe that the alpha girl is a new phenomenon. Nor do I believe that these alpha girls are polar opposites of their mothers. Kindlon focuses a lot on the way the alpha girl emulates or imitates that actions or characteristics associated with the male. Why does it have to be considered a male characteristic. I think that saying that alpha girls view the world differently from their mothers is not true. Just as progress and inclusion and "tolerance" has progressed all across society, so have progressions in gender relations and achievement. Believing that alpha girls have more a sense of entitlement than their mothers just doesn't gel with me. I see these alpha girls that may not have experienced sexism or have tools in their arsenal to combat it, but they know that sexism exists. I just can't imagine that girls who pride themselves so much on academic success, would turn their noses up at studying the women and the struggles that made their dreams possible. I personally believe the things I believe about what women can do, and what I can do as a female from the example of my mother, grandmother, great-grandmother. While their experiences to some extent were vastly different from mine, and many of their experiences I cannot relate to or really grasp the concept of, I still appreciate what those experiences were able to produce for me. Dr. Kindlon has got it all wrong.

2 comments:

  1. Danielle- I agree, alpha girls are not anything new. Confident, powerful, ambitious, uninhibited women have been around for centuries. But I don't think Kindlon is saying that they haven't. Instead, he's arguing that in today's world, there are simply more alpha girls--a young generation today is FULL of them. This, I believe, is new. And the implications for that can't be overstated. Today, there are more women valedictorians than men...more women enrolled in four year universities than men, etc. More and more women are finding themselves unrestricted by gender roles, and although I too have my issues with this book, I certainly think this is a new phenomenon worthy of study.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Lydia to a degree. Any American who has taken a U.S. history course can travel down the list of important female leaders of the past, Betsy Ross, Susan B. Anthony, Clara Barton, etc. However, these women's accomplishments all center around either advancements for women or were contained within the "domestic" domain. There are exceptions to every rule, but by and large, the "alpha girls" of today are no longer seeking to make the same impact on society that these aforementioned women made. Instead, they are looking up to Hillary Clinton, Condoleezza Rice, Oprah Winfrey, etc. as new women and new leaders. While certainly not dominant, women are highly present in influential roles across society (with the exception of the business community). The new alpha girl truly is new phenomena.

    ReplyDelete